May 15, 2024
Updated November 18, 2026
Conceptual vs procedural understanding: which is better? If you’ve taught math for any length of time, you’ve probably heard this debate in a PLC or the staff room, and people usually feel strongly one way or the other. I’d like to suggest we’re asking the wrong question. The better question is what comes first. Today I’ll define both, show you what they look like in an area lesson, and explain what this means for math stories.

Defining conceptual and procedural understanding
Procedural understanding is knowing how to do the math: the steps, the formulas, the algorithms. When a student lines up numbers to add or multiplies length by width, they’re being procedural.
Conceptual understanding is knowing why the math works and what’s actually happening. A student with conceptual understanding can tell you what the numbers mean, not just what to do with them.
Conceptual vs procedural understanding: why people pick sides
Each side has a real worry. The procedural camp worries that if students don’t know their facts and steps, they can’t do anything: they stall as problems get more complex.
The conceptual camp worries that students who only learn steps can’t do anything new: they follow the recipe until the problem looks a little different, and then they’re stuck. You’ve probably had both of those students in your room. The trouble is that the debate treats the two as competitors. Students need both, and every time they meet a new problem, understanding what’s happening has to come before choosing a procedure.

Let me explain what I mean, looking at area through the lens of the Concrete Representational Abstract (CRA) approach.
CRA is how conceptual understanding gets built: students connect what they do with objects (concrete), what they draw (representational), and the symbols they write (abstract). It isn’t a ladder. They move between the phases, often in the same lesson, and the understanding lives in the connections.
Example: conceptual and procedural understanding in a 3rd grade area lesson
Concrete. When students first learn about area, tiles are used to create arrays that represent the length and width of a rectangle. A student builds 2 rows with 3 tiles in each row and counts the total.
Representational. A student draws what they built as a structure: 2 groups (the rows), 3 in each group (the tiles), 6 total (square units). The idea of unit is critical here. If you’ve ever taught area or perimeter, you know students often confuse the labels for their solutions. When the structure shows 6 square units, they can see why.

Abstract. The same rectangle shows up as an equation, 2 x 3 = ?, and eventually as the formula area = length x width. The symbols mean something because the student can move back to the rows they built and drew whenever they need to. A student who only has this step has the procedure without the idea. And a student who writes 3 x 2 isn’t wrong. They’re reading the same rectangle as 3 columns of 2.

How do you know a student understands it?
Ask what the numbers stand for. A student who understands can tell you the 2 is the number of rows, the 3 is how many tiles are in each row, and the 6 is the total, in square units.
As students get comfortable, the drawing gets faster. They move from building the rectangle with tiles to sketching a fast array, (shown below) and eventually they may not need to draw at all because they’re clear on what 2 x 3 means.

Calculating works the same way. Students first work through the operation with strategies they can explain, like skip counting by 3 or breaking a number apart. Once they understand why those strategies work, a procedure, like the standard algorithm, becomes a shortcut they can trust. And when an answer doesn’t make sense or the problem changes, they have a structure to come back to.
Math stories: comprehend first, then compute
Math stories are where this order matters most. Procedures have a place in math, but making sense of a story isn’t one of them. When students struggle with math stories, it’s often because they aren’t sure what’s happening in the story. That’s a reading comprehension issue before it’s a math issue.
Take this 2nd grade story: Marcus has 6 fewer stickers than Jada. Marcus has 8 stickers. How many stickers does Jada have?
Say you notice a student wrote 8 – 6 = 2 because they spotted “fewer.” The arithmetic is right, and the answer is wrong. You might ask: Who has more stickers? Which number tells us about Marcus? What does the 6 tell us? Those questions lead to the math main idea, the relationship in the story: Jada has more than Marcus, and we know by how much. Now the student can show it in a Compare structure, with Jada’s amount as the unknown, Marcus’s 8, and the difference of 6. The equation 8 + 6 = ? matches the story, and so does ? – 6 = 8. Either way, the student still calculates. They just calculate after they know what’s happening.
If you use CUBES or a similar routine, you’re in good company. Most of us were handed one. The trouble is that a student can circle the numbers, box “fewer,” and follow every step without ever reading the story. I explain why in my post on common strategies, and in this video I show what to do instead.
This is the work I also walk through in my book, Structures of Equality, with all three structures and classroom examples.
Conceptual vs procedural understanding: why understanding comes first
I think we’re having the wrong debate. It isn’t all or nothing. Procedures have a place, and so does conceptual understanding. The question is what comes first. Students can’t calculate what they don’t understand, so understanding the rectangle, the story, or the relationship has to come before the steps.
Math stories are where this matters most. Steps for getting through the story, like keywords or CUBES, don’t belong there, because the story is something to understand first. Once students understand, their drawings get faster and the model may become internal. They calculate with strategies they can explain, and a procedure comes last, once they know why it works. Students need both, and understanding comes first.